Siduction Forum

Siduction Forum => Upgrade Warnings => Topic started by: Pip on 2024/05/21, 18:34:28

Title: Solved: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: Pip on 2024/05/21, 18:34:28
apt full-upgrade -
...
Summary:
  Upgrading: 68, Installing: 0, Removing: 351, Not Upgrading: 0


Probably best to proceed with a little caution.
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: humon on 2024/05/21, 21:26:10
Thanks.

I only just read this post.  Earlier today I did a dist-upgrade.  I did not proceed with a little caution.
I boot to the command line now.  Fortunately my system still seems intact once I launch xfce4.  I haven't had time to do full damage assessment, but, yes, a little more caution would have been good.

I look forward to finding out more about what went sideways.
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: thomv on 2024/05/21, 22:44:22
looks like a bigger change in KDE is going on
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: slaughterer on 2024/05/22, 15:07:08
just made a nala upgrade, all clear,to how ever want to proced.
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: Mte90 on 2024/05/22, 16:51:43
There are various qt packages from 5.15.10-2+b2 to 5.15.13-2 and not all the kde packages are updated to use them.
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: hschn on 2024/05/22, 17:11:06
Ich habe hier einen interessanten Vergleich von apt full-upgrade

hier mit dem bisherigen solver:
Summary:
  Upgrading: 94, Installing: 7, Removing: 31, Not Upgrading: 0
  Download size: 66,3 MB / 77,1 MB
  Freed space: 301 MB


hier mit dem neuen solver:
Upgrading: 4, Installing: 7, Removing: 0, Not Upgrading: 90
  Download size: 0 B / 10,8 MB
  Space needed: 30,2 MB / 9.674 MB available


Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: michaa7 on 2024/05/22, 21:30:39
Was bedeutet "neuer solver"? Wie kommt der zum Einsatz?
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: dibl on 2024/05/22, 21:40:39
If you look down to the bottom of the left-most column of dependencies on this table, you will see that plasma-workspace depends on this unfinished transition:

https://release.debian.org/transitions/html/qtbase-abi-5-15-13.html
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: der_bud on 2024/05/22, 21:55:22
Quote from: michaa7 on 2024/05/22, 21:30:39
Was bedeutet "neuer solver"? Wie kommt der zum Einsatz?
Siehe unter anderem: https://linuxnews.de/apt-2-9-3-fuehrt-neuen-solver-ein/
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: michaa7 on 2024/05/23, 01:03:34
Danke, im verlinken Artikel fand sich dann des Rätsels Lösung:

QuoteUm den neuen Solver zu benutzen, muss bei APT 2.9.3 derzeit noch die Option --solver 3.0 mit angegeben werden.

Und interessant wie der wie der arbeitet/interesting how the new solver works:

alter solver/old solver:
apt update && apt full-upgrade -d
...
Summary:                                                                       
  Upgrading: 126, Installing: 1, Removing: 6, Not Upgrading: 2                 
  Download size: 136 MB / 183 MB                                               
  Freed space: 116 MB


Neuer solver/new solver:
apt update && apt --solver 3.0 full-upgrade -d

...
Summary:
  Upgrading: 55, Installing: 1, Removing: 0, Not Upgrading: 74
  Download size: 29,1 kB / 145 MB
  Space needed: 32,7 MB / 3.147 MB available
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: samoht on 2024/05/23, 14:53:40
Here this transition has come to an end.

# LANG=C apt update
...
Fetched 330 kB in 2s (140 kB/s)
All packages are up to date.


Server:
https://deb.debian.org/debian
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: harley-peter on 2024/05/23, 16:54:12
Und was benutzt man jetzt am besten? Mit solver 3.0 oder ohne? Die Unterschiede sind doch nicht ganz ohne:

Mit solver 3.0:
Upgrading: 134, Installing: 3, Removing: 0, Not Upgrading: 50

Ohne solver 3.0:
Upgrading: 199, Installing: 3, Removing: 0, Not Upgrading: 0
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: hendrikL on 2024/05/23, 17:07:10
Was sagt Dir denn der gesunde Menschenverstand?

Die zu entfernenden Bibliotheken werden identisch sein, oder?

Lass den Solver mal außen vor, jener ist bislang nicht ganz ausgereift,  probiere mal ein "apt upgrade" zum Vergleich!
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: harley-peter on 2024/05/23, 17:15:49
Ja, ich denke auch, dass es sinnvoller ist, das gute alte apt so zu nutzen wie bisher. Wäre der neue solver schon perfekt, dann wäre er sicher nicht nur optional. Ist aber allemal interessant den Unterschied zu sehen.
Title: Re: Warning: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: edlin on 2024/05/23, 21:11:05
Ich halte es auch noch für verfrüht, den neuen Solver in den Dauerbetrieb zu überführen. Ich kann nicht wirklich die Unterschiede zu apt upgrade und apt full-upgrade vollends nachvollziehen.
Allerdings gefällt mir der erkennbare Ansatz. Gerade Siduction könnte hier eines Tages profitieren. Wie oft hat sich doch mal ein weniger erfahrener Nutzer mehrere hundert Pakete ,,ungewollt" beim full-upgrade entfernen lassen, nur um danach festzustellen, dass er damit sein KDE/Plasma ins Nirvana geschickt hat.

edlin
Title: Re: Solved: Removals in full-upgrade
Post by: DeepDayze on 2024/05/24, 03:46:24
No removals here as of now, but there might be other packages coming in I'm sure.