grub2-fll-fromiso

[Teriarch]

Unfortunately it won't work:

Code Select Expand

$ sudo ./60_fll-fromiso  
Found fromiso: MX-25.2_KDE_x64.iso on /dev/nvme0n1p4: /srv/ISO/MX-25.2_KDE_x64.iso
Detected bootloader: unknown in MX-25.2_KDE_x64.iso
Skipping MX-25.2_KDE_x64.iso: unrecognised bootloader layoutFor some reason MX-* iso images are not "Full Story" compatible.

[hendrikL]

http://aptosid.com/debian/pool/main/g/grub2-fll-fromiso/

I think you should fetch the whole program, do not pick the cherries.
And I would read the changlog first.

https://github.com/fullstory/grub2-fll-fromiso/blob/master/debian/changelog

[Teriarch]

Well, they say: "The chain is only as strong as its weakest link" and considering
there is only one (apart from the trivial config file), we can even dive deeper
into the detection logic in order to find it:
detect_bootloader.sh (stripped from /etc/grub.d/60_fll-fromiso):

Code Select Expand

#!/bin/sh -e
 
ISOINFO="$(which isoinfo)"
OSIRROX="$(which osirrox)"
 
extract_efi_img() {
        local iso="$1"
        local efi_tmp
        efi_tmp=/tmp/efi.img
        if "${OSIRROX}" -indev "${iso}" -extract /efi.img "${efi_tmp}" \
                        >/dev/null 2>&1 && [ -s "${efi_tmp}" ]; then
                echo "${efi_tmp}"
        else
                rm -f "${efi_tmp}"
        fi
}
 
detect_iso_bootloader() {
        local iso="$1"
        echo Iso Image: $iso
        local efi_img="$(extract_efi_img $iso)" # path to extracted efi.img, or empty
        echo Efi Image: $efi_img
        # grub (BIOS hybrid): kernels.cfg on the ISO9660 layer
        if "${ISOINFO}" -R -i "${iso}" -f 2>/dev/null \
                        | grep -q '^/boot/grub/kernels.cfg$'; then
                echo "grub"
                return
        fi
        # ESP-based: distinguish by FAT contents
        if [ -n "${efi_img}" ]; then
                # grub-efi: kernels.cfg inside FAT under /boot/grub/
                if "${MDIR}" -i "${efi_img}" '::/boot/grub/kernels.cfg' >/dev/null 2>&1; then
                        echo "grub-efi"
                        return
                fi
                # systemd-boot: /loader/loader.conf inside FAT
                if "${MDIR}" -i "${efi_img}" '::/loader/loader.conf' >/dev/null 2>&1; then
                        echo "systemd-boot"
                        return
                fi
                # refind: /EFI/BOOT/refind.conf inside FAT
                if "${MDIR}" -i "${efi_img}" '::/EFI/BOOT/refind.conf' >/dev/null 2>&1; then
                        echo "refind"
                        return
                fi
        fi
 
        echo "unknown"
}
 
detect_iso_bootloader $1
Let's see:

Code Select Expand

$ ./detect_bootloader.sh /srv/ISO//siduction-2025.1.0-Shine_on-kde-amd64-202604141203.iso
Iso Image: /opt/sda5/opt/linux/siduction-2025.1.0-Shine_on-kde-amd64-202604141203.iso
Efi Image: /tmp/efi.img
grub

vs.

Code Select Expand

./detect_bootloader.sh /srv/ISO/MX-25.2_KDE_x64.iso  
Iso Image: /srv/ISO/MX-25.2_KDE_x64.iso
Efi Image:
unknown
Neither does the code detect the /boot/grub/kernels.cfg in the isofs
(well, there is none), nor is he able to extract the efi partition
(though there is one). Do you really think the whole program could
improve on that?

[hendrikL]

...
Well, they say: "The chain is only as Do you really think the whole program could
improve on that?

I don't know, never tried that, nor do I feel to investigate my spare lifetime on it.
It is interesting, for shure.

My intention is to use the whole thing, because the different parts could fit together. And it is not a problem to downgrade when it doesn't work, or?

[Teriarch]

> I don't know, never tried that, nor do I feel to investigate my spare lifetime on it.
> It is interesting, for sure. 
We definitely agree on that. As soon as it interests me I pick the problems from
the forum like puzzles waiting to be solved. I don't care whether it's useful or not,
they have intrinsic value far beyond their usefulness in showing how to approach
a problem and developing solution techniques. And if somebody profits, the better... 

[eriefisher]

Either way, it seems that the fll tools will only work with fll built iso's. There is still away to do it with grub2 so I'll go that route. I still think there should be mention of it in the manual under the grub2-fll-fromiso section. Just to prevent someone else going down this road.